calledges.com 
Dramaturgy analyzes social interaction as theatrical performance, emphasizing roles, scripts, and staging in human communication. Narrative paradigm focuses on storytelling as a fundamental mode of human reasoning, assessing the coherence and fidelity of narratives to evaluate their truthfulness. Explore deeper distinctions and applications of these frameworks to enhance understanding of communication theory.
Main Difference
Dramaturgy focuses on social interaction as a theatrical performance, where individuals manage impressions to influence others, emphasizing roles, scripts, and stages. The Narrative Paradigm centers on human communication as storytelling, highlighting coherence and fidelity to evaluate the persuasiveness of narratives. Dramaturgy analyzes everyday life through symbolic gestures and performance frameworks, while Narrative Paradigm underscores the power of stories in shaping beliefs and decision-making. Both theories explore meaning construction but approach communication from performance versus narrative perspectives.
Connection
Dramaturgy and Narrative Paradigm both analyze human communication through storytelling frameworks, where dramaturgy views social interaction as theatrical performance and Narrative Paradigm interprets communication as coherent, meaningful stories. Both theories emphasize the importance of narrative coherence and fidelity in shaping audiences' understanding and social reality. This connection enables deeper insights into how individuals construct identity and meaning through shared narratives in everyday interactions.
Comparison Table
| Aspect | Dramaturgy | Narrative Paradigm |
|---|---|---|
| Definition | A communication theory that views social interaction as a theatrical performance, where individuals manage impressions to shape others' perceptions. | A communication theory that suggests humans are natural storytellers and that all meaningful communication is a form of narrative or storytelling. |
| Founder(s) | Erving Goffman | Walter Fisher |
| Core Concept | Life is like a stage play; people perform roles to influence others in social interaction. | People understand and evaluate communication through coherence and fidelity of stories. |
| Focus | Impression management, roles, settings, and performances in face-to-face communication. | Storytelling as a means to make sense of experience and to communicate values and reasoning. |
| Key Components | Front stage, back stage, scripts, performers, audience. | Coherence (structural, material, character), fidelity (truthfulness, reliability of narratives). |
| Application | Analyzing social situations, identity presentation, social rituals. | Evaluating persuasive communication, cultural narratives, ethics in storytelling. |
| Communication Type | Primarily face-to-face interactions and social performances. | All forms of communication expressed through narrative structures. |
| Philosophical Basis | Symbolic interactionism; social construction of reality. | Humanistic approach; storytelling as fundamental to human nature. |
Performance (Dramaturgy)
Performance in dramaturgy involves the dynamic interaction between actors, script, and audience within communication frameworks, emphasizing expressive delivery and emotional resonance. It relies on nonverbal cues, vocal modulation, and spatial awareness to enhance narrative impact and convey thematic depth. Communication theory highlights how performance mediates meaning construction, influencing audience interpretation and engagement. Effective dramaturgical performance integrates semiotics and performative acts to create immersive storytelling experiences.
Storytelling (Narrative Paradigm)
The Narrative Paradigm, developed by Walter Fisher, posits that humans are natural storytellers who make sense of the world through narratives. This theory emphasizes the coherence and fidelity of stories, meaning how well a story hangs together and aligns with listeners' values and experiences. In communication, storytelling serves as a fundamental method for conveying meaning, shaping beliefs, and influencing behavior across cultures and contexts. Narrative competence becomes essential for effective communication, as audiences evaluate messages based on their truthfulness and relevance.
Social Roles
Social roles in communication shape interactions by influencing behavior, expectations, and language use within various contexts such as family, workplace, and social groups. Roles like leader, mediator, or participant define how individuals convey messages and interpret responses, impacting the effectiveness of communication. Understanding these roles enhances interpersonal dynamics and facilitates conflict resolution, collaboration, and social cohesion. Research from the Journal of Communication highlights that role clarity significantly improves communication outcomes across diverse cultural settings.
Narrative Coherence
Narrative coherence in communication ensures that stories or messages are logically structured and easily understood by the audience. This concept enhances the clarity and persuasiveness of verbal and written communication by maintaining consistency in themes, characters, and events. Scholars in communication studies emphasize that coherent narratives improve audience engagement and retention of information. Effective narrative coherence supports better decision-making and emotional connection in interpersonal and mass communication contexts.
Impression Management
Impression management in communication refers to the strategic process individuals use to influence others' perceptions during interactions. This concept involves controlling verbal and nonverbal cues such as tone, body language, and facial expressions to create desired impressions. Effective impression management enhances social influence, builds trust, and facilitates successful personal and professional relationships. Scholars like Erving Goffman emphasize its role in everyday social performances and identity construction.
Source and External Links
Narrative paradigm - Wikipedia - The narrative paradigm views all meaningful human communication as storytelling and asserts that people naturally engage with and judge stories based on coherence and fidelity, offering a broad, non-elitist approach to reasoning and belief formation in contrast to traditional logic-based systems.
Letter to a Playwright: How Drama Works Dramaturgically - Dramaturgy examines how drama is constructed and experienced, focusing on the dynamic relationship between narrative, character, and language in performance, and emphasizes that every element on stage--from symbolic expression to character heuristics--can be manipulated, subverted, or reinterpreted within the flow of live theatrical experience.
The narrative paradigm: An elaboration - Sci-Hub - The narrative paradigm is a philosophical framework for interpreting and assessing communication, positing that meaning arises from the interplay of history, culture, and character rather than from formal logical structures, and that every act of discourse invites critical evaluation for its reliability as a guide to action.
FAQs
What is dramaturgy in communication theory?
Dramaturgy in communication theory is a perspective that views social interactions as theatrical performances where individuals manage impressions by controlling their behavior and presentation to influence others' perceptions.
What is the narrative paradigm?
The narrative paradigm is a communication theory developed by Walter Fisher that posits humans understand and evaluate information primarily through storytelling, emphasizing coherence and fidelity in narratives to determine their truth and reliability.
How does dramaturgy differ from the narrative paradigm?
Dramaturgy analyzes social interaction as theatrical performance focusing on role-playing and impression management, while the narrative paradigm views human communication as storytelling structured by coherence and fidelity.
What are the key components of dramaturgical analysis?
Key components of dramaturgical analysis include front stage behavior, back stage behavior, performance, impression management, roles, scripts, and audiences.
What are the main elements of the narrative paradigm?
The main elements of the narrative paradigm are narrative probability (coherence), narrative fidelity (truthfulness or reliability), characters, events, plot, and the logical appeal of storytelling.
How do people use dramaturgy and narrative to make sense of reality?
People use dramaturgy by framing social interactions as theatrical performances with roles, scripts, and settings, applying narrative to organize events into coherent stories that provide meaning, structure experiences, and shape identity.
Why are dramaturgy and the narrative paradigm important in understanding human interaction?
Dramaturgy and the narrative paradigm are crucial in understanding human interaction because dramaturgy reveals how individuals perform social roles and manage impressions, while the narrative paradigm explains how people make sense of experiences and communicate through structured stories.